Gore Shoots His Mouth Off About “Racist Climate Change Deniers”


I found this on Black and Right and decided to comment on it here.

We live in an age where the argument is frequently driven not by logic or fact but by the “controversial nature” of the sound byte.

So Al Gore compares AGW sceptics to the KuKluxKlan. His point presumably is that the “deniers” are clinging to a superseded world view that is morally wrong and discredited.

Except that we are not talking about the KuKluxKlan we are talking about CO2.  We are talking about public energy policy.  So talk about science and utility and economics, not guys in white sheets out of  Birth of a Nation. Of course there can be a moral context to public policy but it is not going to be as clear cut as he wants it. If there was solid science behind AGW than you could make the argument that failure to act could have a damaging impact on a future generation. There may be a moral argument there. I know just enough philosophy to know that is a long serious debate.

But don’t forget there is a compelling moral argument against badly thought out “do-good” actions that benefit a few hyper rich individuals while driving up the cost of energy for the rest of us. Especially the poor.  Making cars harder to come by, coal supplied energy  scarcer, and electricity more expensive can easily be argued as immoral. Let’s look at Cash For Clunkers, a program designed to “help the environment” and the economy by getting older cars off the road. I, for one, found Cash For Clunkers to be immoral. Why?

Well, it drove up the price of used cars so that first-time buyers and poorer buyers had real trouble finding vehicles with which to get to work. I know a guy who could not find the car he wanted for months because of CFC.

Since the cars were destroyed, both the cars and the component parts were off the market making it  harder to find parts for people on lower incomes. The available parts were pricier.

The cars that were redeemed were paid for and operating so the program pulled forward demand and took perfectly good vehicles off the street. Pulled forward demand meant the car companies built more cars based only on subsidized demand which meant they were hurt once the rug was pulled out.

It was paid for with tax money so I was coerced into buying your new car which you didn’t need and wouldn’t have purchased unless my money was extorted from me and given to you. My tax money was thus used to hurt me and poorer people in one swipe. There was also a nasty surprise for the buyers because the tax burden on the “gift” was real and large.

Of course in the Al Gore world of argument I would say that President Obama was like Hitler bribing Germans with Volkswagens while his Stalinist minions swept across the land like man-eating locusts (Hitler and Stalin in a two-fer) and Gore  would call me an anti-American killer of future generations because I was opposed to removing “clunkers” from the street and allowing industry to flourish. BLECH

To return to climate change. We need the arguments and should debate the science. But is has nothing to do with the late Sen Robert Byrd, Hugo Black or any other Klansman turned Democrat luminary. Let them rest, whether in peace or in hell.

This entry was posted in Blogging Support, Climate. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Gore Shoots His Mouth Off About “Racist Climate Change Deniers”

  1. Tom says:

    Cash for Clunkers did take a lot Obama bumper stickers off the road!

    • Yes, and that is a very good thing. I saw an Obama supporter yesterday wearing a 2008 t-shirt with “He’s Ready To Go!” emblazoned on the back. First time I ever agreed with the sentiments on an Obama t-shirt, but I wonder if the guy’s irony meter is broken….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s